So I don't mean to go all Negative Nancy on you again, nor am I someone looking to pick a fight with other parents. However, let's get one thing straight here: spanking is a cutesy name for beating.
If you spank your child, you are beating him.
I belong to many mother/parenting Yah.oo! listservs. I think they are phenomenal resources from finding out where to buy a gently used Ci.ty Mi.ni to the best infant swim classes in the area to listening to advice on infant b.m.'s. <---Yep, I went there.
Recently, a mother sent out a plea to her fellow mothering comrades. In sum: My 3 year old is batshit crazy. He won't listen. I'm out of my mind. What do I do?
E-mail responses were sent directly to this mother with an anonymous compilation blasted out to the entire group. I read every. single. response. Why? Well, I knew something was going to
rub me the wrong way, and who doesn't love a little argument within one's own mind and then a relevant blogpost?
I digress.
Here is the most stunning, stop in my tracks, find the husband, sit him down on the couch, read and scowl response that I came across:
We spanked/ spank ( typically developing) daughter. (we also have a daughter with Special needs but she is not spank-able YET). When she was younger we spanked a lot more than we do now. We used a wooden spoon and called it Mr. Ugly. We would say, "do we need to get Mr. Ugly?" It was a nicer way in public than saying I am going to spank you or you need a spanking. When we thought she was old enough to be spanked I took her to the store to buy the wooden spoon and explained to her that this will be used to discipline her. We always spanked her bottom (it was hard at times as she would thrash around). you want to make sure that it does sting a little or they won't get the message. This punishment worked works for us. What we have learned is that you have to be Consistent. If you are not consistent then the child will figure out ways to get what they want or get away with bad behavior. you can say over and over.. I am going to get Mr. ugly... ditto ditto.. you have to just do it!I had a harder time being consistent in public. I would take my daughter to the truck and use Mr. Ugly. (yes I had to carry a smaller one in my purse for a while).We took a Dr. Dobson study on Discipline. it really helped us! I do not have many friends that spank. They use time out but feel that this way of punishment has worked for us. http://www.beliefne t.com/Love- Family/Parenting /2005/02/ Do-Not-Spare- The-Rod.aspxA funny not... when at friends home and they are using a wooden spoon my daughter was for a while terrified as to why it was out of the drawer and being waved around! :) look mommy... Mr. Ugly..... :)
Wow. WOW. Mr. Ugly? Wooden spoon? Terrified child? Under what circumstance does this necessitate a smiley face!?!?
I am deeply distraught by the fact that this parent not only found this behavior acceptable, but adorable! She even states that they may most likely will use this same tactic with their younger child; a child with special needs no less. In times like these, I am so thankful that the compilations to such questions are anonymous because it would take all of my willpower not to retaliate on this individual.
Now this is where I ask a question.
However, none of this is up for discussion in my view point.
It is what it is: TRAGIC.
How would you respond in such a situation?
Would it be appropriate to blast out another response to the entire group,
condemning spanking beating?